In my experience...I have used 2 different New Accounts to do this 2 or 3 times on a weekly basis...I have been doing this for a few months now...without any problems at all...
The first New Account had been limited and then had the limit lifted...I was waiting for the account to age so I could get the debit card...so for about 2 months I used my Old PP, which has the debit card, to request money from this New Account...
The New Account (1) I was using Mozilla and the Old PP (2) I used AOL...
I would...
Open Mozilla
Log into (1) then check balance (lets say $286.87), log out
Close Mozilla
Clear Cookies
Open AOL
Check IP w/ IPBurger (Make sure its diff then Mozilla)
Log into (2)
Create a "Money Request" to (1) for $272.00 (remember there will be a fee)
Click "Service"
Title: Something like "June Payment"
Body: the due date and "for fixing car" or something like that
Send Request
Close AOL
Clear Cookies
Open Mozilla
Open Gmail - the email account for (1)
Click the email
Click the link
Log into (1)
Scroll down, click "No Shipping Needed"
Hit "Pay Now"
Check Balance - make sure money is sent
Log Out
Go to the ATM, check balance, withdrawal about $260 ($1 fee)
I did this 2 or 3 times a week transferring $200-$400...Both accounts had the same first and last name too...worked every time w/o any problems...Ive since gotten the debit card for that account so I moved onto doing it with another New Account that im waiting for the debit card...diff name on this one...still works...withdrawing to a bank account it too risky you may never get your money...and don't ship out items till you have that money in your hands...
 | 
