Ebay AI is determinating each item as replica

[Karlis96]

Hello.
I have aged 5+ years and about 20+ feedbacks from branded items second hand sold. Some of them 10k+$
Now i list branded but cheap item 100$ and its third time since december when ebay remove listing as replica and gave me warings.
They whrite in email its AI decision.

How it can be ? Every single item goes under replica.

[rsot]

Third time removing listing? You're playing with fire trying to relist it.

What is the item or category Karlis96? Need to be clear

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by rsot

Third time removing listing? You're playing with fire trying to relist it.

What is the item or category Karlis96? Need to be clear

Its not same item three times in a row )

It is same category but diferent color.

It is Hermes brand. All items is Hermes.

As i said, have sold many, but since dec 2025 ebay bot is removing all items

[agent006140]

Hermes,is it knockoff?

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by agent006140

Hermes,is it knockoff?

No.
All items is authentic

[ahmaed]

When you appeal for listing ending, explain why AI is wrong, they will fix it

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by ahmaed

When you appeal for listing ending, explain why AI is wrong, they will fix it

I have appealed one of two ended listings. And i explained there for ebay, i can list whatever i want but this AI will take it down anyway.

Lets see what will happen

[agent006140]

The rep cant change the AI behavior ,it has to be their Tech dept.
Did you take your own photo or use stock photo?
What about other sellers?
You cant be the only Hermes seller?
I see plenty of used HERMES scarves on Ebay !

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by agent006140

The rep cant change the AI behavior ,it has to be their Tech dept.
Did you take your own photo or use stock photo?
What about other sellers?
You cant be the only Hermes seller?
I see plenty of used HERMES scarves on Ebay !

Sure, always using only my own photos. Never had used stock photos.
Others still selling if you mean that. There is many sellers who sell Hermes stuff.

[rsot]

Could it be competitors reporting you to bring you down?

[murdered_by_ebay]

likely lack of selling history , seems to be similar to amazon where ungating brands takes previous history. here it seems to be AI version of the same which can not gate but removes instead

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by rsot

Could it be competitors reporting you to bring you down?

No, listing doesnt goes live.

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by murdered_by_ebay

likely lack of selling history , seems to be similar to amazon where ungating brands takes previous history. here it seems to be AI version of the same which can not gate but removes instead

It is immpossible. 2025 year sold on about 50k€
Selling history i have. All positive feedbacks for brand.

[rsot]

Do you have any other accounts right now with active listings live?

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by rsot

Do you have any other accounts right now with active listings live?

No, i have only one account.

I gave this two items to my friend who has also account on ebay but with much more less selling history, and he was listed those items.
He sold both items sucessfully. AI didnt take them down.
But if i list those items they will be taken down.

How this can be explained ?

[murdered_by_ebay]

Originally Posted by Karlis96

It is immpossible. 2025 year sold on about 50k€
Selling history i have. All positive feedbacks for brand.

you said yourself 20 feedbacks , bot programming could have been adjusted

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by murdered_by_ebay

you said yourself 20 feedbacks , bot programming could have been adjusted

And others can sell in same time despite on bot programming ?

[murdered_by_ebay]

Originally Posted by Karlis96

And others can sell in same time despite on bot programming ?

are your accounts registered in major countries?

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by murdered_by_ebay

are your accounts registered in major countries?

It is not related with countrys.

Before i told you my friend who has also selling account with much less selling history ( 2026 year account ) can sell all those items what i can not sell anymore.
Its not related with country.

[rsot]

Originally Posted by Karlis96

No, i have only one account.

I gave this two items to my friend who has also account on ebay but with much more less selling history, and he was listed those items.
He sold both items sucessfully. AI didnt take them down.
But if i list those items they will be taken down.

How this can be explained ?

Difficult to explain - his account hasn't been flagged like yours perhaps...and his listings are flying under the radar

[murdered_by_ebay]

from my experience uk , usa , germany and a few others get preferential treatment. smaller ones are stricter but if the country does not matter here then AI might have red flagged the actual account

[Karlis96]

Originally Posted by murdered_by_ebay

from my experience uk , usa , germany and a few others get preferential treatment. smaller ones are stricter but if the country does not matter here then AI might have red flagged the actual account

This can be true.
I will try to fight with ebay to remove this red flags :(