| Sandy D | 01-12-2014 08:08 PM | Re: NFL Season 2013 has begun Quote:
Originally Posted by vogeltron
(Post 518943)
I think another head to head matchup of Brady vs Manning. Even though it is a team game. Since Brady has had the upper hand for so long and such a better playoff record etc. If Brady beats Manning to go to the Superbowl this will leave Manning behind Brady in the QB discussion. If Manning wins it could bring save his relevance and help him get past that Postseason woes he has had his entire career. |
Like you said this is a team game and Brady has had a ton of awesome talent helping him while Peyton did not have teams even close to the talent the Pats have had over the years. Good teams but not great overall teams like Brady has had.
I dont think I could chose one over the other based on who won super bowls as that would be like saying that no player in MLB deserves to be a HOF because his team never went to a World Series.
Manning I think has the over edge between the two as I dont look at how many super bowls someone went to because many great QBs never went to any super bowls.
What you do not know is I have been following the Pats for years because they play like the Boston Red Sox, gritty, never give up and fight to the end but Peyton is a rare breed who knows the game far beyond any QB I have watched.
And dont forget, Pats coach is probably the best ever. |