Item removed that i have been selling for years..

[Dexter-uk]

Hi everyone, recently an item that i have been selling for around 4 years on ebay on a good till canceled listing was removed due to copyright. Now i know i would be foolish to relist the item again but would you think it would be ok to do so in say a year from now? thanks

[GreenBean]

No.

Once removed, it will be removed again.

Either never list it again or obtain the rights to list.

Avoid danger to your account

[rsot]

You must obtain the rights in WRITING from eB. Do what is needed to get it if you can.

[Dexter-uk]

Originally Posted by rsot

You must obtain the rights in WRITING from eB. Do what is needed to get it if you can.

When i spoke to an ebay rep they just said i need to contact the rights owner, of who i did and they said no as not allowed to use there name as is trademark, even though there are other sellers who have sold 1000s of the same item and have been doing so for years like myself.

[GreenBean]

Originally Posted by rsot

You must obtain the rights in WRITING from eB. Do what is needed to get it if you can.

FFS, rsot.

If you must give advise try to give as close as possible to being correct that you can manage.

ebay ALWAYS instruct the seller ( if they even bother to reply) to get the consent of the RIGHTS holder.

Stop with misleading info .

[GreenBean]

Originally Posted by Dexter-uk

When i spoke to an ebay rep they just said i need to contact the rights owner, of who i did and they said no as not allowed to use there name as is trademark, even though there are other sellers who have sold 1000s of the same item and have been doing so for years like myself.

Your advice from ebay is standard.

When there is a VeRo take down, the seller needs the OK from the rights holder.

Problem is that with a UK listing you may never get that permission. ebay UK also do not allow sellers to file a claim disputing MC019...

Seems like you came up against an aggro IP holder....did you make a formal approach?

[JamesNorth101]

You will need to get permission from the right holder before you can sell that item again

Just because other can still sell it does not mean that you can, they may have the right holders permission.

Dont relist this item again unless you get permission in writing.

[Dexter-uk]

Originally Posted by Greenie

Your advice from ebay is standard.

When there is a VeRo take down, the seller needs the OK from the rights holder.

Problem is that with a UK listing you may never get that permission. ebay UK also do not allow sellers to file a claim disputing MC019...

Seems like you came up against an aggro IP holder....did you make a formal approach?

Within the mc email from ebay there was the rights owners email, so i sent them an email just asking if with there permission i could continue to sell the item and would happy pay a 'copyright fee' if thats what they wanted. They emailed back saying that any 'Jaguar' branded items using the logo or there name are not to be sold and that they take it very seriously. Even though there are over a quarter of a million 'jaguar' related items on ebay.

[GreenBean]

That company is known to be 'hard' on enforcing their rights .

Know of someone whose account got killed for listing a Jaguar key-ring.

Not 3 quid of merchandise but no account....

Absoultely proceed with caution here.

Sorry to say.

[rsot]

Originally Posted by Dexter-uk

Within the mc email from ebay there was the rights owners email, so i sent them an email just asking if with there permission i could continue to sell the item and would happy pay a 'copyright fee' if thats what they wanted. They emailed back saying that any 'Jaguar' branded items using the logo or there name are not to be sold and that they take it very seriously. Even though there are over a quarter of a million 'jaguar' related items on ebay.

There are sellers who have experimented with various Vero items and learned to keep under the radar.

There are also those sellings that just havent been caught by Eb yet.

Ebay can go 90 days into the past - pull listings - warn buyers - issue suspensions on that - and make the seller suffer.

[jeffweico]

The sad fact is, when it comes to trademarks, the rights owners have most of the power. Some rights owners would prefer their products were never sold on eBay. So, even if the item is legitimate, they have it removed.

You COULD try to sell it on a different account, but you would have to make sure that EVERYTHING about the listing is different - pictures, description, title, etc.

And, there is no guarantee the rights owner would not remove the new listing as well.

But to re-list on the current account would be inviting account suspension.

[waterproof]

I have had the same restriction happen to myself. Listen to the Bay and DO NOT continue relisting, especially if you think you will get away with it "just one more time". You will get MC'd and back on the Forum you go.
I have been waiting for a little over 1 year for my particular catagory to be revised. I know that it will, but I know that I have to wait patiently on the Bay.

It has been VERY tempting, but please wait for the Bay to give you the GO. It may take 2 or more years for them to revise and update your Catagory, BUT it is out-of-your-hands, so just sit back and wait.

ALSO, keep all of your Contacts and their e-mails! There is life and Sales 'outside' of the Bay!!!

Good Luck!
waterproof

[Dexter-uk]

Thanks for all the advice guys, i wont be listing these anymore so would be very unwise.

[GreenBean]

Originally Posted by Dexter-uk

Thanks for all the advice guys, i wont be listing these anymore so would be very unwise.

Best choice.

Save the account first and foremost.

Good Luck

[rsot]

Originally Posted by Dexter-uk

Thanks for all the advice guys, i wont be listing these anymore so would be very unwise.

Hope you have other things for seling